(Article of periodic en Anglais - 2012)

Document title

Seeking good peer review in geomorphology

Authors(s) and Affiliation(s)

LANE S.N. (1) ;
(1) Inst. Géographie, Univ., Lausanne, SUISSE


This paper provides an extended guide to reviewing for "Earth Surface Processes and Landforms" in particular and geomorphology in general, considering what makes a fair and constructive review. The A. identifies six elements of a good review and notes the importance of a constructive review, grounded in what is written in the manuscript, justified where appropriate and avoiding reference to personal views as far as is possible. He concludes with a discussion of whether or not the reviewer should sign his review openly and the importance of reviewer confidentiality


Article of periodic

published at : Earth surface processes and landforms / ISSN 0197-9337 / CODEN ESPLDB

Editor : Wiley, Chichester - ROYAUME-UNI (1981)

Millesime : 2012, vol. 37, no1 [pp. 3-8]

Bibliographic references : 18 ref.



INIST-CNRS, Cote INIST : 17355

Digital Object Identifier

Go to electronic document thanks to its DOI : doi:10.1002/esp.2269

Tous droits réservés © Prodig - Bibliographie Géographique Internationale (BGI), 2012
Refdoc record number (ud4) : 26260597 : Permanent link - XML version
Powered by Pxxo